docs(brainstorm-with-docs): обновлена документация скилла

- Зачем:
  - README и ROADMAP должны отражать текущую модель скилла без устаревшего handoff.
- Что:
  - удален временный DEV-HANDOFF.md.
  - README уточняет отличие от grill-me и роль grill-with-docs как upstream influence.
  - ROADMAP фиксирует R2/F4 как landed и описывает F1 как cheap frame-challenger.
- Проверка:
  - git diff --check -- agents/.agents/skills/brainstorm-with-docs.
This commit is contained in:
Dmitry Dementiev committed 2026-06-06 17:26:57 +03:00
1 parent a1fe4ce319
commit 14adf77424
3 files changed
+43 -101

No files matched your search

@@ -12,15 +12,25 @@ proposes documentation, but stops before code, config, or infrastructure changes
## Why this exists
It combines three things that are usually separate:
It combines four things that are usually separate:
- **shared domain language** (glossary / `CONTEXT.md`) and **lightweight ADRs** —
the discipline of capturing terminology and durable decisions as they crystallise;
- **active grilling** — not just extracting requirements, but pressure-testing
them: challenging terms against the glossary, sharpening fuzzy language, probing
with edge-case scenarios, cross-checking claims against the code;
- **option exploration** — always comparing 2-3 viable approaches with trade-offs
before recommending a direction.
- **option exploration** — comparing 2-3 viable approaches within the user's
framing, plus at least one framing-challenger so the agent does not only
optimise inside the first shape of the problem;
- **durable output** — turning the useful thinking into the smallest appropriate
artifact: glossary entry, spec, ADR, runbook, research note, or PRD.
The closest day-to-day comparison is `grill-me`: use `grill-me` when you mainly
want the agent to pull understanding out of you and align on a plan in the
conversation. Use `brainstorm-with-docs` when the discussion must be grounded in
the repository and leave behind project documentation. `grill-with-docs` is an
upstream influence for glossary and ADR discipline, but this skill is not trying
to follow that methodology wholesale.
## Usage
@@ -59,15 +69,16 @@ Templates are split per type so the agent loads only what's relevant
## Roadmap
- **v1 (current):** working hybrid — context inspection, glossary/ADR discipline,
active grilling, option comparison, durable artifacts, stop-before-implementation.
- **v2 (planned):** a *divergence phase* before option synthesis (an
idea-generation toolkit plus the rule "at least one option the user didn't
already imply"), a "design for isolation" lens, and fuller multi-context
support. A `<!-- SEAM -->` marker in `SKILL.md` step 5 marks where it slots in.
active grilling, option comparison with an additive framing-challenger, durable
artifacts, stop-before-implementation.
- **v2 (planned):** tiered fuller divergence for heavier decisions, an
idea-generation toolkit, a "design for isolation" lens, and fuller
multi-context support. A `<!-- SEAM -->` marker in `SKILL.md` step 5 marks where
it slots in.
See [ROADMAP.md](ROADMAP.md) for the full backlog, pending decisions, and what
has been considered and rejected. (Dev-phase docs — `ROADMAP.md` and any
`DEV-HANDOFF.md` — can be removed once the skill stabilises.)
has been considered and rejected. `ROADMAP.md` is development memory and can be
removed once the skill stabilises.
## Attribution
@@ -77,7 +88,9 @@ from two MIT-licensed projects:
- **grill-with-docs / grill-me** by Matt Pocock —
<https://github.com/mattpocock/skills> (MIT, © 2026 Matt Pocock).
Source of the glossary/`CONTEXT.md` discipline, lightweight ADRs, and the
active grilling techniques.
active grilling techniques. This skill deliberately diverges from
`grill-with-docs` where the user's workflow needs broader artifact creation and
option exploration.
- **brainstorming** by Jesse Vincent (obra), from Superpowers —
<https://github.com/obra/superpowers> (MIT, © 2025 Jesse Vincent).
Source of the explore-context → question → compare-options → present-design flow