refactor(skills): переработан плейбук координации Codex
- Зачем: - Актуализирована координация под Astra с сохранением замысла и бюджета контекста. - Что: - Разделены роли Astra, Sol и Luna; выбор приемов оставлен координатору. - Сохранены независимое ревью, триаж и проверка соразмерности исправлений. - Обновлены нативные механики и необязательная линия Claude CLI. - Проверка: - Проверены Markdown-ссылки, YAML и git diff --check; описано ограничение валидатора. - Пройден поведенческий сценарий с тремя тестами и независимое ревью Claude. - Перепроверены находки и фактическое продолжение фоновой сессии Claude.
This commit is contained in:
1 parent
65c802f8fc
commit
3a72ce906f
11 files changed
+538
-686
No files matched your search
+29
-25
@@ -1,40 +1,44 @@
|
||||
## Mandate
|
||||
## Reviewer mandate
|
||||
|
||||
- Review independently and test hypotheses. Do not edit source files,
|
||||
persistent environment state, or Git.
|
||||
- Use the working permissions needed for checks, caches, temporary artifacts,
|
||||
documentation, and primary-source research.
|
||||
- Write the detailed report only to REPORT. This assigned exchange file is the
|
||||
sole write exception to the observer mandate.
|
||||
- Treat another agent's claims as untrusted until evidence supports them.
|
||||
- Review the stated version independently. Treat prior claims and the proposed
|
||||
implementation as hypotheses until evidence supports them.
|
||||
- Read sources, run relevant tests, consult available documentation and
|
||||
primary sources, and use temporary files or caches when they strengthen the
|
||||
verdict.
|
||||
- Preserve source files, Git, services, data, and other persistent state.
|
||||
Write the detailed result only to REPORT.
|
||||
- Judge defects at the reviewed artifact's own level and price a proposed fix
|
||||
against the risk it removes. A finding is a claim, not an order.
|
||||
|
||||
## Detailed report
|
||||
|
||||
Use stable IDs with FINDING PREFIX:
|
||||
Use permanent IDs with FINDING PREFIX.
|
||||
|
||||
`PREFIX-N | BLOCKER|MAJOR|MINOR|NIT | file:line or task section | violated
|
||||
criterion | failure scenario | evidence | minimal verification`
|
||||
`PREFIX-N | location | violated criterion |
|
||||
failure scenario | evidence | minimal verification`
|
||||
|
||||
A non-gating consideration has no stable ID, severity, or counter. Use it only
|
||||
for a material risk from a safely deferred decision, and do not prescribe the
|
||||
downstream implementation. It does not change the verdict.
|
||||
When the project or review line already defines a severity scale, add severity
|
||||
to the record and count it.
|
||||
|
||||
Use CHANGES_REQUESTED only when at least one finding requires revision at the
|
||||
reviewed artifact's own level. APPROVED means that no such defect remains; it
|
||||
does not mean that every downstream question has been answered.
|
||||
A non-gating consideration has no ID, severity, or counter. Use it only for a
|
||||
material risk of a safely deferred decision. It does not change the verdict.
|
||||
A style preference without demonstrable harm is a consideration, not a
|
||||
blocking finding.
|
||||
|
||||
If there are no findings, record the reviewed scope and every executed check
|
||||
or tested hypothesis with its outcome. A bare approval is invalid.
|
||||
`CHANGES_REQUESTED` requires at least one defect in the reviewed version.
|
||||
`APPROVED` means no such defect remains. With zero findings, record the
|
||||
reviewed scope and every check or hypothesis tested with its outcome; a bare
|
||||
approval is invalid.
|
||||
|
||||
## Final message
|
||||
|
||||
Return only:
|
||||
|
||||
- `VERDICT: APPROVED | CHANGES_REQUESTED`
|
||||
- severity counters;
|
||||
- one line per finding: `ID | severity | area | one-phrase essence`;
|
||||
- optional one-line material considerations:
|
||||
`CONSIDERATION | area | one-phrase risk`;
|
||||
- `REPORT: <absolute path>`.
|
||||
- available counters
|
||||
- one line per finding with ID, area, one-phrase claim, and any established
|
||||
severity
|
||||
- every material consideration, one line each
|
||||
- `REPORT: <absolute path>`
|
||||
|
||||
Do not repeat the detailed report or reasoning narrative in the final message.
|
||||
Do not repeat the detailed report.
|
||||
Reference in new issue
Block a user