docs(skills): brainstorm-with-docs — правки по холодному ревью

README перестал объявлять скилл ручным: model-invocation — намеренное
текущее состояние (триггер — форма задачи, не область). Жёсткий гейт
получил исключение для глоссария (спорил с шагом 4) и стал единственным
владельцем запрета на реализацию; дубли правил схлопнуты к владельцам.
Отложенные находки (шов self_review, критерий конца интервью, версионные
пометки в шаблонах) — в Pending decisions ROADMAP.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
Dmitry DementievandClaude Opus 5 committed 2026-08-01 18:40:38 +03:00
1 parent e3021ce372
commit d10ad6981c
3 files changed
+70 -39

No files matched your search

@@ -1,11 +1,11 @@
# brainstorm-with-docs
A manually-invoked skill for **brainstorming, design alignment, and durable
documentation** — grounded in a project's existing docs and vocabulary. It takes
an unclear engineering, DevOps, architecture, migration, integration, research,
or documentation problem and drives it to shared understanding and a recommended
direction — recorded in the *smallest useful* durable artifact: a spec, ADR,
runbook, research note, or `CONTEXT.md` glossary update.
A skill for **brainstorming, design alignment, and durable documentation** —
grounded in a project's existing docs and vocabulary. It takes an ambiguous
problem — whatever the domain — or a decision fork (развилка) and drives it to
shared understanding and a recommended direction — recorded in the *smallest
useful* durable artifact: a spec, ADR, runbook, research note, or `CONTEXT.md`
glossary update.
It is deliberately **not** an implementation skill. It reads project files and
proposes documentation, but stops before code, config, or infrastructure changes
@@ -36,19 +36,18 @@ to follow that methodology wholesale.
## Usage
Invoke manually:
Model-invoked: the agent reaches for the skill on its own when it sees an
ambiguous problem or a decision fork (развилка) — the trigger is the shape of
the task, not its domain. (It started life manual-only; live use showed the
whole value is in the agent reaching it unprompted.) You can also invoke it by
name:
```
/brainstorm-with-docs <problem-or-topic>
```
On **Claude Code** the skill is manual-only (`disable-model-invocation: true`) —
it never auto-triggers; you always call it. On **Codex** that field is ignored
(Codex reads only `name` + `description`), so it may auto-trigger on matching
design tasks. The negative triggers in the description discourage that, but the
description's positive surface is broad (architecture / DevOps / research), so
expect it to fire more eagerly on Codex than on Claude. If that gets noisy,
narrow the description.
A repo can route to it explicitly — e.g. an `AGENTS.md` line sending decision
forks here.
## Layout
@@ -56,6 +55,7 @@ narrow the description.
brainstorm-with-docs/
├── SKILL.md # the skill: process, rules, grill mechanics
├── README.md # this file
├── ROADMAP.md # development memory: status, backlog, evidence
└── artifacts/ # output templates — read only the one you need
├── spec.md # solution design / engineering spec
├── research-note.md # exploratory, answer not yet known
@@ -70,18 +70,9 @@ Templates are split per type so the agent loads only what's relevant
## Roadmap
- **v1:** working hybrid — context inspection, glossary/ADR discipline,
active grilling, option comparison with an additive framing-challenger, durable
artifacts, stop-before-implementation.
- **v2 divergence (current):** step 5 is a diverge-then-converge split — frame
restatement, mandatory frame-challenger and null option, fan width tiered by
decision weight, an idea-generation toolkit with WHEN-triggers, a diversity
self-check, and fork-in-place grilling during the interview (step 4).
- **Remaining:** a "design for isolation" lens and fuller multi-context support.
See [ROADMAP.md](ROADMAP.md) for the full backlog, pending decisions, and what
has been considered and rejected. `ROADMAP.md` is development memory and can be
removed once the skill stabilises.
Status, backlog, pending decisions, live-test evidence, and rejected ideas live
in [ROADMAP.md](ROADMAP.md) — the single source of truth. It is development
memory and can be removed once the skill stabilises.
## Attribution