# Narrow re-check

Continue from your original review. Read that report, the resolution report,
and the new reviewed version. Re-check only your original findings and changes
immediately adjacent to their resolution.

For every `FIXED` or `REJECTED` ID report `CLOSED`, `NOT_CLOSED`,
`REJECTION_VALID`, or `REJECTION_INVALID` with concise evidence. Carry
`OUT_OF_SCOPE` and `NEEDS_DECISION` into the index unchanged; do not
re-judge them or include them in your verdict. They remain open for their
owner. Judge a rejection by its contract and evidence. For a `FIXED`
resolution also report
`PROPORTIONATE` or `OVERREACH`; put your own earlier prescription on trial
and price added complexity against the risk it removes.

Narrow scope limits exploration, not honest reporting. Give a newly exposed
adjacent defect a new stable ID and return it for triage. `OVERREACH` is an
upward signal and does not by itself reopen the original defect.

Preserve sources and persistent state. Write the detailed re-check to REPORT.
Return only:

- `VERDICT: APPROVED | CHANGES_REQUESTED`;
- status counters;
- one line per original or new ID: `ID | status | one-phrase essence`;
- `REPORT: <absolute path>`.