fix(codex-playbook): уточнён вердикт ревью планов

- Зачем:
  - ревью высокоуровневых документов могло требовать преждевременных деталей и постоянно блокировать одобрение.
- Что:
  - находки ограничены дефектами на уровне самого документа.
  - существенные отложенные риски отделены от блокирующих замечаний.
  - уточнено, что APPROVED допускает открытые вопросы будущей реализации.
- Проверка:
  - quick_validate.py, git diff --check и проверка локальных Markdown-путей.
This commit is contained in:
Dmitriy Dementiev committed 2026-07-13 14:09:25 +03:00
1 parent 70b18b9e9a
commit 02a98df8c3
3 files changed
+35 -3

No files matched your search

@@ -76,9 +76,23 @@ REPORT: absolute unique path
`review-focus.md` задаёт один выбранный фокус. Для постановки:
```text
Review the task statement, not an implementation. Check facts against code,
hidden one-line decisions, boundaries, checkable acceptance criteria, and
ways to satisfy the wording without the intended result.
Review the statement or plan at its own level of abstraction, not as an
implementation. Check facts against code, hidden one-line decisions,
boundaries, checkable acceptance criteria, and ways to satisfy the wording
without the intended result.
A high-level document is not incomplete merely because implementation choices
remain open. Request changes only for a defect the document itself must
resolve: one that changes its goal, boundaries, architectural direction,
acceptance criteria, dependencies, or the ability to decompose work safely.
When a detail can be decided locally by a downstream owner without changing
those properties, do not make it a finding or prescribe the implementation.
If deferring it carries a relevant risk, record that risk as a non-gating
consideration.
APPROVED means that no defect at the document's own level requires revision.
It does not mean that all downstream questions have been answered.
```
Для реализации выбери task lens или code lens из договора ревью: